Former CIA analyst and author of The Revolt of the Public, Martin Gurri, joins Mitch Daniels to discuss how the digital information tsunami toppled institutional authority and fueled populism worldwide, and why AI, humility, and America’s Jeffersonian spirit leave him optimistic about freedom’s future.
▼ View Full Transcript
Intro (00:02):
Welcome to The Future of Liberty, a project of Liberty Fund, hosted by Mitch Daniels.
Mitch Daniels (00:16):
Greetings, everyone, and welcome to the latest edition of The Future of Liberty, a product of the Liberty Fund, an organization who has been devoted for over six decades to the preservation and promotion of the freedoms for which America is known. And today’s guest, though he will modestly disclaim it, I know, is widely credited, including by me, with having first spotted the trends and the underlying causes of the growth of what is loosely termed populism, not only in this country, but in many others around the world. A former, for almost three decades, analyst at the Central Intelligence Agency, Martin Gurri is now one of our eminent scholars operating out of the Mercatus Institute for which all of us at Liberty Fund have such great respect. Thank you for joining us.
Martin Gurri (01:10):
Well, for once, I’m not going to be lying to say that it’s an honor to be here.
Mitch Daniels (01:21):
Many of our listeners will be thoroughly familiar with your pathbreaking work in the book The Revolt of the Public in two editions and then since then, but please summarize for us what you discerned in terms of the causes of so much of the disruption we now see in societies here in Europe and elsewhere.
Martin Gurri (01:44):
Well, it was a strange origin story. As you say, I was in the CIA for many years. Alas, I didn’t have a license to kill. I had probably the least sexy job there. I was an analyst of global media, which amazingly turned out to be the strategically most important place to be just because that’s the way that history was turning.
(02:10):
I mean, to put it in perspective, when I was a young analyst, the flow of open information was a trickle. I mean, a trickle. Even in developed countries like France, if the president said, “How are my policies playing in France?”, you would go to two newspapers. I mean, that’s it. They were authoritative. You went to them, and you went back with your answer. Suddenly, around the turn of the century, there was this digital earthquake that produced and propelled a tsunami of information. And that’s unprecedented in human experience, and that’s not just words.
(02:57):
The year 2001, for example, the amount of information in that year doubled that of all of human history, going back to the cave paintings of the dawn of culture. 2002 doubled 2001. Hasn’t quite kept up to that doubling every year, but almost. And so, we were first overwhelmed as analysts like, what’s authoritative in this thing? I mean, there’s gigantic amounts of information. France was suddenly flooded with all kinds of weird online voices that we had no idea about. Places like Egypt that had a tiny, tiny trickle of media suddenly were afloat with, again, new voices that we didn’t know who they were.
(03:42):
So, we were kind of overwhelmed by the size of the thing, that explosion of information that, professionally for us, was very difficult because we couldn’t go back to the two newspapers. And of course, today this sounds trivial, but at the time, we were very perplexed. As different countries digitized at different rates, this tsunami rolled around the world. Behind it, there were ever-increasing levels of social and political turbulence. So, that was like, what is that about? We thought the internet was kind of like the telephone or something. It was a means of communication. Why is this happening? And when I left the government, that’s when I dedicated myself to analyzing.
(04:31):
My answer is that our institutions basically were established in the 20th century during that time of information death, the tiny trickle, and they were authoritative because each had its own source of information. So, newspapers told you this is what’s happening in the world. You had no alternative sources to go to. So, you go, “Wow, I have to read the newspaper.” Walter Cronkite every night would tell you, “And that’s the way it is.” I mean, 30 minutes of mostly visuals, but that’s the world right there for that day. When a president spoke and said there’s a crisis because of X, Y, or Z, what difference did we know? We knew nothing. Suddenly, the public which couldn’t speak back was not only speaking back but yelling and was very angry for reasons that are not entirely clear.
(05:26):
And the institutions that were basically founded on a semi-monopoly of information lapsed into crisis, and that has been basically aggravated every day that goes by.
Mitch Daniels (05:42):
And you taught those of us who are your faithful readers that the loss of that monopoly of information led very directly to an undermining of the authority and the respect which people felt toward institutions and the elites who had been running them.
Martin Gurri (05:59):
Right. I mean, everything is out now. The problem with the old way of dealing with things, the old industrial 20th-century approach to problems, is that it’s a weird way to describe, say, a sociological or economic condition, as if it were a mathematical problem that you could solve. You know, how do you get to be a famous politician? You say, ‘I know how to solve this. I have the solution. I can do this. I can do that.’ And we didn’t know any better. You either succeeded or failed. But what this tsunami has done is open up the stage so that every mistake you’ve made before, every stupid thing you’ve ever said before, every time you’ve flirted with someone who wasn’t your wife, all these things come out. And so, authority has crashed. It has completely crashed. It was an authority based on opacity, and now we’re in a world of transparency.
(07:06):
I mean, think of JFK and the reputation he has. He was very protected by the media. I’m not saying good or bad, but that’s just the way it was. And today, that would not be that way. Every one of those dates that he had would be spilling the beans online.
Mitch Daniels (07:25):
So, let’s take a quick tour around that world that you have analyzed, and we’ll work our way back to our own situation. But you recently wrote a very, I thought, interesting essay about the war fever in Europe and where you think it comes from.
(07:45):
What’s going on over there?
Martin Gurri (07:48):
I was taken by the fact that everybody in Europe is suddenly hysterical about an invasion from Russia. Emmanuel Macron, president of France, held a very, very well-publicized meeting with all top politicians, except the extremes, in France in which the intelligence services briefed the inevitability of war with Russia. The Brits had the same thing. They’re saying strange things like, “Our children are going to die, are going to go die in East Europe,” and the Germans are saying the same thing.
(08:26):
And it struck me as, what the heck is going on here? Because the Russians couldn’t beat Ukraine. And if you can’t beat Ukraine, how are you going to invade Western Europe, and with what resources? I mean, the Russian economy is smaller than Italy’s, so where are they going to find the resources to invade? So, it was doubly strange because these countries had been essentially pacifistic for the last 20 years. Since the end of the Cold War, they had basically maintained a pacifistic policy. And now, suddenly, they’re all changing course. And I think if you look at it closely, all three countries, France, Germany and Britain, are run by this sort of establishment elite class that is under siege, absolutely under threat, and being defeated elsewhere around the world. They can see the dominoes falling in their direction.
(09:25):
And they need, number one, a rallying cry. I mean, that’s an old tradition that the French call “The fatherland is in danger.” Well, that unifies everybody around you, right?
(09:43):
But, number two, there’s this thing about the Russians being master manipulators, which by the way, if it’s true, what failed when they invaded Ukraine? I mean, within 24 hours of the invasion of Ukraine, Zelenskyy was a hero, and Putin was a stage villain, so somehow the manipulation failed. But that’s the fame that they have been given in Europe. And so, they can now tar all their populist and anti-establishment groups with, “You are tools of a foreign power,” and censor them. And they censor them very vigorously, by the way. They arrest them. They find them. Some of them, not that many, end up in jail, but some of them do. And essentially silence the opposition and give themselves a slightly longer lease on life. That’s my idea as to why they’re doing it.
(10:43):
They actually probably believe it because these are people who are very strange. It’s easy to believe what you want to believe. So, I’m not accusing them of insincerity, necessarily, but my belief is they’re doing it because they know they can get a political advantage out of it.
Mitch Daniels (11:05):
In South America, over recent years, there has been a number of transitions that appear to be in the direction of more regard for free markets and free exchange and so forth. Is that a real philosophical shift, or is this simply another set of elites, who happen to be more leftists, being overturned, and we can expect, when dissatisfaction comes to the new regimes, that it’ll just flip the other way?
Martin Gurri (11:34):
I mean, I come from that part of the world. And honestly, I’d like to be optimistic, and it’s an optimistic moment, but it’s hard to be optimistic because Latin America is, I would say, a sway between extremes. That’s just the way their politics go. They go all the way in one direction, realize, “Oh, this is terrible,” and then they go all the way the other direction, and then somebody says, “No, that’s terrible too.” And then the cycle starts again.
(12:04):
Let’s see if it’s different. I mean, the history is surprising. And sometimes there are permanent changes. And it would be lovely if Latin America could shed its idea, I mean, this very old-fashioned idea of revolution, that went down with the Soviet Union, for goodness sakes, and you see the examples of those who still stick to it, like the Ortegas in Nicaragua and the Castro family in Cuba, and they’ve popularized their country. It’s obvious. Everybody can see it. So, why would you want to follow that anymore? This just doesn’t work.
(12:43):
And interestingly, in Milei, in Argentina, they have found somebody who I think is a model. For a fact, he was a model for the DOGE here for Musk. And in Europe, you’re hearing people say that we need to do what Milei has done. And of course, in Brazil, we just had an election that looks again like it’s going to turn away from socialism. They’re saying, “We need to do what Milei has done.” So, that’s rare for Latin Americans to set a model other than for something horrible like revolution.
Mitch Daniels (13:21):
One place where digitization hasn’t at least yet seemed to undermine the ruling elite and its institutions, in this case, one institution, is China. What lessons can we take out of China? Is it just the exception that proves the rule, or will eventually these same factors bring change there?
Martin Gurri (13:43):
The factors are all there. And I’ll give you an example for that. When at the end of a terrible repressive attempt to impose a zero-COVID policy where, I mean, there are videos of people jumping from balconies or whole apartment blocks, everybody’s screaming, “Let us out,” because they literally would nail the door shut, something broke. The Communist Party got together in Congress and said, “Nope, zero COVID, and we’re going to do it.” And something broke in the population, and they went out on the streets. They started yelling for the first time. It wasn’t just, “We’re unhappy.” I mean, “You Communists are dictators.” And within two weeks, the COVID policy was gone, and was eliminated. They were terrified.
(14:35):
So, my take is China has been prospering. And the Chinese I have met, many of whom are anti-Communist, say, “Yeah, but my grandfather grew up in a hut, and I’m a millionaire, and so why should I rock this boat?” That’s not a permanent situation. I think actually they’re not growing as they used to. But my take on it is that all the conditions for a revolt are in place in China the moment the public decides to revolt. And the question is, why does that happen? That’s an interesting question.
Mitch Daniels (15:13):
So, here in the US, we see, I think very plainly, the wisdom of your accuracy of your analysis. So, let’s start with the question, which came first? Granted that they’re mutually reinforcing institutional failure or the digital polarization that’s now so clear?
Martin Gurri (15:39):
I mean, my take on it would be that human life is messy. Institutions are messy. They succeed at some things. They fail at some things. They pretend to be very methodical and very logical and very structured, but everything seeps around the edges. It’s human. Humans are messy. The problem is, with that industrial mindset of the information monopoly, that was denied. They said, “No, we know. We know the answers. We know the solutions. You have to do this. You have to do that.” And we, of course, even if we disagreed, we had no alternative but to go along with it.
(16:21):
I think what came first was the messiness of the human condition, and what came second was it was unmasked. And then, it seemed like these people, these elites, these politicians, these bureaucrats.
Mitch Daniels (16:35):
Scientists.
Martin Gurri (16:35):
Scientists were hypocrites, were pretending to be people who knew, but they seemed to know about maintaining their power. Everything they decided seemed to somehow feather their nests but not necessarily solve the problem that they kept talking about. And of course, all the failures became apparent, part of the messiness of the human condition. I don’t think it was massive corruption or anything like that. It’s like we live in a different world than we were told we lived in.
Mitch Daniels (17:08):
Many of us who fret about the condition of freedom and the future of it here in the country try to watch and understand whether the American people still are somewhat more resilient, more committed, to the habits of self-government than maybe other places where maybe they haven’t even yet developed or had experience with democracy. You recently said during a visit to the Liberty Fund, “The American people are suffering a psychotic episode,” and elsewhere you have written about authoritarian temptation.
(17:47):
If we are maybe slipping down a slope described in that way, how far? And is it reversible?
Martin Gurri (17:55):
Well, I mean, I think if you quote me fully, I said it’s a psychotic episode. One of the great advantages I have over most of you is I come from another country. I’ve been here so long, I am part of it, but I can put my Cuban brain on and kind of get a distance. And I feel like, I mean, we’ve had this collision with the tsunami. We’ve had this disintegration of institutions that were foundational to modern life. We’re going through a psychotic episode, but I have every faith that, considering what I know of people everywhere else, that the American people, once we get taken to therapy and get our wits back, will resume what is its absolutely trademark character which is common sense.
Mitch Daniels (18:56):
And maybe some sense of individualism and personal autonomy that’s a little stronger than in other places?
Martin Gurri (19:05):
Vastly stronger than other places.
(19:10):
There’s always a question in my mind about the extent to which something like that is a legal framework. I mean, the First Amendment, thank God for that. But I think far more powerful is the culture. And I feel like, if you look at American history, which is a fascinating history unlike that of any other country in the world, other countries have battles, but here we have institutions groping and trying to come up with solutions. If you look back, at a certain point, we had John Adams institute the Alien and Sedition Acts and whatnot, and Jefferson took him on and basically wiped the floor with him. We became Jeffersonians. We became Jeffersonians. And he said in his first inaugural address, ‘Error may be permitted so long as reason is free to refute it.’ In other words, we don’t cancel this information. We refute it.
(20:09):
I think Jefferson’s kind of like the old ancient Greek legislators which were more than lawgivers. They imprinted people, almost. I think we’re all imprinted with Jefferson, and I think there’s a culture of, yes, individualism and of standing up for your dignity in this country that is a hard thing to break, and nobody has.
Mitch Daniels (20:37):
I’ll say since, and not if, because I think you’ve proven the point, but since there is now a maybe unprecedented skepticism about institutions, resentment of those who’ve been leading them, deep distrust, is it a paradox that this is happening while the central government of this country has more power than it’s ever had?
Martin Gurri (21:03):
If the government were marginal, nobody would care what it did. It’s because the government’s fingers are everywhere. I mean, they’re telling you you’re too fat. Nothing is too cosmic or too personal. They’re involved in everything. The climate, your weight, whatever. So, no, I think the claims of the institutions have only magnified. I mean, the ultimate nonsensical climax of that was the COVID pandemic, when we were told to do all these things that made absolutely no sense in terms of preventing or blocking infection or stopping the virus. But they were destructive to the economy, destructive to mental health and terrible for the education of our children. We will be paying for that for many years.
(22:00):
And once the peril was over, people took a deep breath and said, “What the heck was that?” If the government had just taken a sensible approach and laid back and let the American peace and said, “These are your options. This is what you can do. These are your perils. This is what you maybe should try to avoid,” and then trust us as adults, the resentment that exists over what happened, I think we’re still feeling, and we will for many years. There’s a political blowback. This is all over the world, by the way, that people feel like you did all these things to me because you said that COVID was happening, and now that we have the data, we know that you were absolutely wrong. You and all your experts were essentially acquiring power and prestige and being on television every day and becoming stars and were loving it.
(22:48):
And meanwhile, you were telling us, “Lock yourself at home,” doing things that previous plans that had been laid out in advance said, “Never do this. Doesn’t make any sense. You can’t prevent this. You can’t quarantine an entire population. You have to wait ’til the virus goes through.” I think, basically, the more intrusive the institutions have become everywhere, the more distrust.
Mitch Daniels (23:21):
Some of us were bothered. Granted, there was grumbling here and there and some protests, but we were pretty acquiescent as a people in the lockdown mentality. But you think we’ve learned a lesson: it would be harder for a government to impose that a second time.
Martin Gurri (23:37):
I think we were all scared. I think that the revolt of the public came to a skidding halt. I mean, if you look at the year 2019, there were revolts in something like 20 or 30 countries from Somalia to Hong Kong, to Santiago, Chile, I mean all over the world. In 2020, they all stop.
(23:54):
We were scared. And suddenly, we wanted to believe that the government really knew what it was doing and that they could solve this problem. And we put ourselves in their hands, and that’s what they did with it. So, I think there is a double sense of betrayal because we did that.
Mitch Daniels (24:12):
Theorists of democracy in the past have generally agreed that an informed, literate, presumably educated, populous is another prerequisite. Now, we’ve never had more information, as you illustrated and quantified, and yet we seem less, not more, committed to the freedoms and the system of self-government that we had.
(24:40):
Is that a paradox, or can you square that?
Martin Gurri (24:43):
Well, I mean, I guess I would challenge the premise.
(24:50):
I mean, what is informed? You can know every little detail about the Iran war. What does that make you? It makes you a head full of clutter, I think. Or you can be somebody who looks at a politician, and you are informed about their character by the words that they use or the things that they say. And it’s not necessarily book learning. It’s more understanding of the people that we’re electing, which I think is what happened in the 19th century. There were newspapers that people read. You read a Lincoln speech, and you suddenly knew that you had a special person in your hands, right? So, you don’t have to keep up with the news. If you read Walter Lippmann, he’ll tell you you don’t anyway. Your head is full of stereotypes and clutter because you have to simplify. You can’t help yourself, otherwise your head explodes.
(25:50):
And today, it explodes over and over again. So, no, I would push back on the premise. I think we need wisdom. I don’t think we need information, and that’s just a very different thing. And you can’t add up information and arrive at wisdom. It’s an entirely different path.
Mitch Daniels (26:09):
So, maybe we’re not the most informed society to date. We’re the most misinformed. We’re overly informed to the point where we can’t find wise judgments.
Martin Gurri (26:22):
Well, we are the way we always have been. We’re selectively informed. I have a secret belief. I couldn’t prove it as an analyst, so it’s just speculation, but I have a secret belief that that’s the way we’ve always been. In other words, if you were a Protestant in the old days, you thought a certain way. If you’re a Catholic, you thought a certain way. Information bent in this direction or bent in that direction, and you selected. And you selected. You selected it here. And it was the same world, but some way or another we ended up in different places. I think it’s always been like that. I can’t prove it.
(26:53):
I think now it’s front and center at the center stage. We’ve moved that divide, the fact that we inform ourselves differentially, moved it into center stage because everybody’s talking. All those people were just talking to their friends and neighbors. Now, they’re out in the public square yelling and screaming.
Mitch Daniels (27:15):
Do you see any government or any individual leader somewhere on the world stage who has found some sort of formula for rebuilding trust, the sort of general confidence that allows any institution to move forward? Is Milei an example, or are we still looking for the first one?
Martin Gurri (27:40):
I think we’re looking for the first one. What happens in this world is the ones that succeed, and I would say Milei is a success so far, and Trump, who’s probably going to get trounced in the midterms, but he is a success. He has done almost revolutionary things that nobody thought could be done, but what happens is that inspires this other side to a frenzy. And there is no trust because, whichever side is in office, the other side basically isn’t saying, “I disagree.” It’s saying, “You’re a liar, a cheat, and a thief.”
(28:17):
The people who voted for Trump or are MAGA followers, they trust him implicitly, but there’s a whole lot of Americans that don’t. Same as in Argentina, when you look at the other side, it is the exact same thing. They think he’s starving children, and people are dying because of the government being so starved for wealth and stuff like that.
(28:44):
So, I think we’re in for a rough ride for a few years, and maybe this is the way it’s going to be. It’s really not about individuals. It’s about institutions and whether they can adapt. Somehow, there’s this Darwinian process of structural adaptation, and the question is whether institutions can land in a place where they can function smoothly without constantly getting battered by a tsunami of information and AI.
Mitch Daniels (29:15):
You’re probably our most astute, you’ve certainly been our most prescient, observer of media and these new trends. So, let me ask you this. We’ve all learned that there’s an inner dynamic or internal dynamic and a commercial dynamic that pushes in the direction of information that inflames and incites and is negative in a general sense. That’s what leads to clicks. That’s what sells ads. That’s what drives this current situation. It’s hard to look at that and be optimistic that we might work our way out of a world in which every fault of a leader is magnified or even blown out of proportion where any achievements, any fine qualities, are obscured.
Martin Gurri (30:08):
Well, I think that depends on the qualities of the leader. I think, if you present yourself as, “I embody the solution to these problems,” and you call unemployment a problem, “Which I have the mathematical solution for, an equation,” or discrimination or inequality or whatever, “I have the solution,” then you’re going to get torn down because, let’s face it, you don’t have that.
(30:36):
But, if you say, “I think we can try something here that’ll get us moving in the right direction,” there has to be a rhetoric of modesty that is necessary in this world in which everything is transparent, in which you make yourself transparent to say, I’m not Moses at the mountaintop. I’m not coming down with the tables of the law. I have an idea. If we try this, let’s see if it works. If not, we’ll go in this direction.
Mitch Daniels (31:02):
So, a dose of personal humility would help.
Martin Gurri (31:06):
Enormous.
Mitch Daniels (31:07):
What about a concomitant of that, modesty or humility about what the government can do even at its best?
Martin Gurri (31:17):
That’s a discussion that doesn’t get heard much these days. What is it? Where’s the line? And we know there’s a line. Everybody knows there’s a line. I’ve been in the government. I know there’s a line. And I was in the CIA which could do things that most governments can’t, but there was a line. And going over that line is just, number one, asking for trouble because you’re not going to be able to achieve what you think you’re achieving, and, number two, eroding trust because you are now invading a space that belongs to somebody else, and they’re going to be found out, and you’re going to be kicked back to where you belong.
(31:55):
So, I think there needs to be a discussion. What is the best way? For example, the economy. Obviously, the government has a big part to play in the economy, but what is it? It doesn’t control the economy, which many politicians around the democratic world will tell you, yes, you can. You can’t just throw a tariff at somebody and decide, well, this is going to fix this. You need a discussion that says, what is the circle of government effectiveness? And then, if you’re in a war or something, you can break that circle and get beyond that. But otherwise, focus on what you can do. That’s what every company does. I mean, if you’re selling sneakers, you’re not going to try and get the government to give you a contract for building aircraft or something like that, building fighter planes. You’re selling sneakers. That’s what you do. The government is selling sneakers. What is that? What is a government sneaker? Good question.
Mitch Daniels (33:07):
Now, when I’ve read your writing on this very point, it makes me, not for the first time, long for Calvin Coolidge.
Martin Gurri (33:17):
Yes.
Mitch Daniels (33:18):
But could a Calvin Coolidge, given the proven failures of government and so forth, could appeal, both originating in personal modesty but also modesty about government’s scope and claims. Can you imagine prospering in this information environment?
Martin Gurri (33:40):
Yes, I can. And I think his greatest modesty of all was rhetorical. Silent Cal. And I think the greatest challenge today is that.
Mitch Daniels (33:55):
Nobody is silent.
Martin Gurri (33:55):
Nobody can shut their mouth.
(33:59):
So, yes, I think that model would work.
Mitch Daniels (34:04):
Well, I hope someone will come along and at least give it a try. It’d be an interesting one.
(34:12):
You wrote in one place or another these somewhat dispiriting words, “We have entered a period of revolutionary change that cannot achieve consummation. Our institutions are in a zombie-like state.” So, I think I get your meaning, but say a little word about consummation and what that means.
Martin Gurri (34:34):
Well, I mean, I think, and I wrote that about 12 years ago, so that was then. This is now.
(34:44):
It’s a little bit of what I said before. I think we’re at a great culling of the institutions, driven, as I said before, by this Darwinian need for structural adaptation. Our institutions are adapted to the industrial world and the monopoly of information. The world today is the exact opposite of that. And some of these institutions are going to adapt. Some new institutions are going to be born, and some institutions are just going to break down, and we’ll remember them as, “Oh, remember the days when we could?”
(35:21):
So, which are which? I mean, I am not a prophet. I have never made a prediction in my life. You want to be wrong and be proven not to know what you’re talking about? Make a prophecy.
(35:31):
But I can guarantee you those three categories will be there. And although, at that point, I was observing that there was this gridlock that wasn’t going anywhere, I think the situation has advanced a little bit more. And you can see that there are certain institutions, even the federal government, that have basically launched the first AI application for public use. And guess what? They put it out there, and it didn’t collapse. Listen, when I was in government, every digital device that was tried collapsed on first use. You have no idea how terrible the government was when it came to digital technology.
Mitch Daniels (36:14):
We remember. The Obamacare website was one of those.
Martin Gurri (36:18):
That one was famous, but let me tell you. I experienced many, many non-famous ones where I literally, at some point when I was doing analysis of the internet, which I thought was an important thing, although not everybody agreed with me, I had to go home to do it because, in my office, I couldn’t get through. I couldn’t get through to all the places that I needed to go. So, that’s changed. The fact that they have now done this AI platform, I think AI could revolutionize government. I think AI can revolutionize, can really, really crimp the power of the bureaucracy. It can make it a lot more transparent.
(37:03):
Every citizen should be able to learn every contract that the government puts out, who are the people involved, how friendly have they been in the past? All that. We’re now reaching a whole new level of transparency. And probably the first reaction is going to be shock and anger, but I think the second reaction, it’s going to be a cleansing of the government.
Mitch Daniels (37:26):
One can hope. People less cautious or modest than you do make prophecies. And from a variety of directions, some pretty persuasive, I think, commentary suggests that we are probably headed for one of those every-two-or-three-generation cataclysms of some kind. They do happen. Our revolution maybe was one, but the Civil War and the Great Depression and so forth. World War II. Some think it could be military. Some think it could be driven by debts that we suddenly can’t sustain.
(38:09):
Here’s the question. Should that come to pass, institutions will be swept away or altered. First, what are the prospects of something like that happening, not just an evolution, but something revolutionary occurring?
(38:29):
And secondly, what kind of society might emerge on the other side? What new institution’s better suited to the new world?
Martin Gurri (38:35):
I mean, I think it’s happening. I think it is happening. I think we are under revolutionary conditions today. I think war is always possible but unlikely. For example, they talk about a civil war happening in the United States. You need a lot of young people, young men, and a lot of testosterone in society and some true institutional ideological divides. In Spain, it was the Catholics and the Communists. I mean, those two people had to kill each other because there was no middle ground. And we don’t have the young guys. We don’t have testosterone, and we don’t have that kind of a divide. It’s a lot of talk.
(39:17):
But there is a revolution. The revolution is that our world is changing around us faster than we can make sense of it. And what emerges on the other side? God knows and probably nobody else.
Mitch Daniels (39:33):
Not even AI?
Martin Gurri (39:35):
Well, AI is close to God.
Mitch Daniels (39:37):
I was leading the witness there.
Martin Gurri (39:39):
You can ask Claude at the end the question.
Mitch Daniels (39:43):
Well, thank you so much for this conversation. I end each one of these with the same question, and I’ll ask you with some trepidation because most of our guests have found a way to be optimistic about this, but you’re an honest analyst, so I know I’ll get an honest answer.
(40:02):
In the year 2050, will Americans be more or less free?
Martin Gurri (40:11):
That’s an act of faith. You can’t predict. And so, I have always been, as you can tell from my writings, short-term very pessimistic, but long-term optimistic because that’s the trajectory of the United States of America. So, I’m going to say more.
Mitch Daniels (40:30):
So, from very different starting points and premises, you’ve come to the same answer that most of our guests have and that I think we at Liberty Fund all hope for.
Martin Gurri (40:41):
Because they’re Americans. If you ask a Russian, they’ll say, “Well, of course, less freedom,” because Russians are gloomy and pessimistic. Americans still today have that Jeffersonian ideal of, “No, of course it’s going to get better.” And every American, almost every American, will respond that way.
Mitch Daniels (41:03):
Well, Martin Gurri, thank you so much for joining us today. Thank you more so for the most illuminating work I think we’ve seen in recent years. Many of us have learned so much and look forward to continuing to learn from your assessments.
Martin Gurri (41:17):
Well, thank you very much, and I look forward to continuing talking with you.
Mitch Daniels (41:21):
And we look forward to your joining us on future episodes of The Future of Liberty, product of the Liberty Fund. Thank you for being with us.
Outro (41:30):
The Future of Liberty has been brought to you by Liberty Fund, a private educational foundation dedicated to encouraging discussions of the ideal of a society of free and responsible individuals.

